|
Piano
Lessons And Spatial Temporal Reasoning
RESEARCH
SHOWS THAT PIANO LESSONS increase the Spatial-Temporal Reasoning
skills of school children.
Introduction
Studies by
Gordon Shaw of UC Irvine posited a model of brain structure that
"suggested a relationship between musical and spatial reasoning
abilities." This hypothesis lead Frances Rauscher of the
University of Wisconsin and Dr. Shaw to investigate specifics of
this hypothesized music/spatial reasoning relationship.
|
|
|
|
|
Spatial-Temporal
Reasoning skills are fundamental for professions that
include biochemistry, mathematics, and piloting, to name a
few.
|
|
|
|
Earlier
studies showed a link between listening
to music by Mozart and subsequent performance in Spatial
reasoning tests.
In the new
study, Drs. Rauscher & Shaw (1997
) decided to examine whether musical training would positively
impact Spatial-Temporal Reasoning (STR) skills, skills
considered to be the building blocks for improved performance in
math and science.
The Experiment
78 preschool
students at a Los Angeles inner-city school were tested using a
standard control/treatment methodology. The students were
divided into the following control and treatment groups:
-
A control
group received no after-school training.
-
One group
of students received 6 months of 1/2-hour after-school classes
in piano keyboard lessons.
-
Another
group received lessons in computer literacy.
-
A final
group took lessons in singing.
Students
were given tests in Spatial-Temporal reasoning and spatial
recognition before the training began, again at the end of the
training, and once again 24 hours later.
The Test
The students
involved in the study were given four tasks from the Performance
sub-test of the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of
Intelligence-Revised (WPPSI-R).
-
One task
was an Object Assembly task, which required arranging
puzzle pieces together
-
Additionally,
students had to perform tasks that tested spatial recognition;
one dealt with a visual match and subsequent drawing of a
figure
-
Another
required the subject to match patterns using flat,
dual-colored blocks
-
One other
task had the children place colored pegs in holes under
same-colored animals
|
|
|
|
The Object
Assembly Spatial-Temporal Test required students to
put together pieces that would form an animal (In this
case, a camel).
|
|
Results
Tests showed
no statistically significant improvement in the control group,
or in the groups that received computer literacy or singing
lessons. However, the group that received the piano instruction
improved by more than one standard deviation in their STR scores
(Improvement by .6 standard deviations or more is considered
statistically significant). Those scores were maintained 24
hours later in the final STR test, linking the improvement to
long-term memory.
|
|
|
|
Only
the group taking piano lessons showed a statistically
significant improvement in Spatial-Temporal skills.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The
relationship between keys and pitch is what's key to
triggering Spatial-Temporal Reasoning.
|
|
|
|
The Hypothesis
Rauscher and
Shaw further hypothesize that it is the relationship between the
physical distance between keys on the keyboard and the aural
pitch of the corresponding notes that triggers the development
of STR skills.
More Information
Based on the
above findings, Dr. Shaw founded the M.I.N.D. Institute in 1998,
in an effort to infuse piano instruction into the K-6 curriculum
in Southern California schools and help improve student's
subsequent abilities in math and science. In the five years
since it's inception, the program devised by the Institute is
being used by more than 40 schools in school districts across
California, Missouri, New York, Oklahoma, and Virginia.
Joshua
S. Bleier
Graduate Student
Educational
Technology, SDSU
|